Sunday, January 12, 2020
Explore the Ways Strong Feelings About Love Are Presented
Poems are commonly used to convey strong feelings about the true nature of love. However, these feelings can take many different shapes which articulate positive as well as negative perceptions of love. The four poems that embody these different features are ââ¬ËHourââ¬â¢ by Carol Ann Duffy, ââ¬ËSonnet 116ââ¬â¢ by William Shakespeare, ââ¬ËIn Paris with youââ¬â¢ by James Fenton and ââ¬ËQuickdrawââ¬â¢ by Carol Ann Duffy. Two poems that share similar feelings about love are ââ¬Ëin Paris with you' and ââ¬ËQuickdraw' as they both explore the theme of conflict and emotional pain instigated by love.Fenton makes it clear in the first stanza that the speaker has been hurt in the past, claiming that he was ââ¬Ëone of your talking wounded' which is a pun on the phrase ââ¬Ëwalking wounded'. However, this phrase is pursued by a. Use of neologism ââ¬Ëmaroonded' which serves to create an apparent carefree tone carried on through-out the poem. However, as the p oem progresses it becomes apparent that the light-hearted mood hides a deeper subtext and is a cover for the speaker's true feelings.Similarly Duffy makes use of an extended metaphor ââ¬Ëa western stand-off', using the slightly chilidish image to to conceal her true feelings and the more serious emotional pain which results from love. She makes use of lexical choices from the semantic field of battle or a western style stand-off ââ¬Å"guns, trigger, Sheriff, last chance saloonâ⬠to reflect how she is feeling in the relationship as well as avoiding the reality of the issue. Despite the light-hearted tones of the poems, the reader's attention is drawn to the subtle darker subtexts which reveal the speakers' true feelings in both poems.Fenton indirectly adresses the speakers true feelings about love by using an ambiguous phrase ââ¬Ëin paris with you' repetitively. However, towards the end of the poem it soon becomes clear that ââ¬Å"parisâ⬠is a euphemism for love. Lo ve is really what the speajer is trying to convey but in a cautious way clearly due to a phobia of rejection or further emotional pain experienced in previous loving relationships. Duffy makes the speakers feelings know in a slightly indirect way as well by the use of enjambment in the phrase ââ¬Ëyou blast meâ⬠¦ hrough the heart', the sudden break in the line highlights the effect te lovers words have on the speaker by enabling through ââ¬Ëthrough the heart' to stand alone consequently stand out. With ââ¬Ëheart', being the main of love and ââ¬Ëblast', related to warfare, being married together, they significantly emphasize the true pain the speaker is experiencing from the lovers' use of weaponry ââ¬Ëyour voice a pellet' as well as a real depth of her vulnerability. In addition, the two poems make use of structure to convey their strong feelings about love to the reader by manipulating the form and layout of the poems.Duffy uses sonnet structure in ââ¬Ëquickdra w', which is a structure traditionally used for romantic poetry. A sonnet consists of 4 stanzas, each stanza containing four lines, also known as a quatrain which are reminiscent of Shakespeare. However, the sonnet structure in ââ¬ËQuickdraw' doesn't quite reflect the common structure of a sonnet as it is brocken up by the use of enjambment and caesuras ââ¬Ëblast me (stanza 2)â⬠¦ throught the heart (stanza 3)' and ââ¬Ëanother one's(stanza 3)â⬠¦ oncealed(stanza 4)' which can be enterpreted in different ways, perhaps it is used to symbolize the breakdown of communication in the relationship or maybe it was used to highlight important words. ââ¬ËQuickdraw' is also wiritten in free verse, so there is no order to the poem as a result it is effective as it replicates the subject of a western ââ¬Ëstand-off' or ââ¬Ëshowdown' which similarly have no order to them and are generally chaotic. Correspondingly, ââ¬Ëin paris with you' is also manipulated so that the st ructure and form of the poem emphasizes certain elements of the relationship.The third stanza is indented and contains nine lines as opposed to the other stanza's which contain five lines. The evident change in structure in stanza 3 is imposed to highlight the speaker's rejection of all the cliches of love by using colloquial language ââ¬Ëcan we say sod off to the sodding Notre Dame', which juxtaposes the classic image if Paris:the city of love. Therefore, an idea of the speaker's clear fear of having to commit theirself to a relationship, after being ââ¬Ëbamboozled' by the ââ¬Ëmess' of the previous ones, is suggested.Nonetheless, despite the speakers in both poems' reluctance to admit the emotional pain and conflict they are suffering, the true extent of their feelings towards their lovers is made very clear by their poignant last lines. ââ¬Å"In paris with youâ⬠ends with the speaker directly adressing their subject of their affection by saying ââ¬ËI'm in Paris w ith you', thereby making it clear to the reader that they are in fact ââ¬ËIn love with you' if you replace ââ¬Ëparis' with ââ¬Ëlove'.The phrase is repeated several times through-out the poem and suggest that no matter how much the speaker denies their feelings, they are unable to hide them. The extra line in stanza 5 suggests the speaker is breaking free of their old thoughts about love and opening up to new ones. Similarly the speaker in ââ¬Å"quickdrawâ⬠ends the poem with the ambiguous phrase ââ¬Å"take thisâ⬠¦ and thisâ⬠¦ and thisâ⬠.The breakdown of language and the use of ellipsis and repetition could be interpreted in different ways, it could suggest that the speaker has been left defensless against the blows of her lover. Alternatively it could be that she finally succumbed to her feelings and is showering her partner with kisses as the bullets are described as ââ¬Ësilver', so precious and expensive. The last lines of Quickdraw are effective as they are very much open to interpretation so the reader is left with different ideas about how the speaker is feelings.Conclusively, the strong feelings about love presented in ââ¬Å"In Paris with youâ⬠and ââ¬Å"Quickdrawâ⬠are highly interesting and evocative with Duffy's use of extended metaphors and Fenton's use of repetition and euphemism. Both of the speaker's ability to get the reader to empathise with them indicates the clear effectiveness of the poem's language, structure and context. The layered deeper meanings and subtexts, hidden beneath the light-hearted tones of the poems, are especially effective.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.